So What Club

Making operations better, and planning for what can go wrong

A dairy plant in Gujarat that cannot keep up in summer

Steps on the bottling line and their capacity(bottles per hour)
Steps on the bottling line and their capacity
StepMachines or packing stationsBottles per hour, eachStep capacity per hour
Fill23,0006,000
Cap17,0007,000
Label14,5004,500
Pack into crates31,8005,400

The prompt

A dairy in Gujarat, India bottles flavoured milk. In summer, shops want 5,500 bottles an hour, and the plant runs 16 hours a day. Each bottle earns INR 6 of contribution (price minus the costs that move with each bottle). The steps, machines and rates are in the table with this case. The plant manager wants to buy a faster filling machine. What should the dairy do? (The dairy is fictional and the figures are illustrative.)

Before you reveal anything, plan your own structure and first move on paper. Then reveal one part at a time and compare.

Clarifying questions, with the interviewer's answers

The exhibit

Steps on the bottling line and their capacity(bottles per hour)
Steps on the bottling line and their capacity
StepMachines or packing stationsBottles per hour, eachStep capacity per hour
Fill23,0006,000
Cap17,0007,000
Label14,5004,500
Pack into crates31,8005,400

Next case

Read the next worked case the same way: plan your own answer first, then reveal one part at a time.

Facts checked against sources on

Spotted something wrong or out of date? Report a mistake. We check every report and correct the page.